France Is the Canary in the Coal Mine

By Paul Vallas

October 30, 2026

France is showing the rest of the world the epic failure of socialism and open borders.

What is happening in France didn’t come out of nowhere. It didn’t “happen yesterday.” It’s the outcome of fifty years of political decisions, made by the left, the far left, as well as the right, who have taken turns in power. Few countries have spent so much money demonstrating at such scale how quickly a rich and capable nation can exhaust itself when comfort replaces responsibility.

France has spent decades turning every political problem into another excuse for more state intervention, more taxation, more spending, more regulation and more dependency, while opening its door wide to a flood of immigrants. The result is a country that spends enormous sums, taxes heavily, runs chronic deficits while delivering deteriorating public services, industrial decline and permanent political paralysis.

Few countries spend so much while leaving such serious questions about what their citizens receive in return. France’s national statistical agency reported that public spending reached 57.3% of gross domestic product in 2025. The budget deficit was 5.1% of GDP, and public debt stood at 115.7%.¹ Those are not partisan talking points. They are clear measures of a country that is spending beyond its means.

At the same time, successive governments treated mass immigration as if integration and assimilation would happen automatically. Instead of controlling its borders, carefully screening new arrivals, demanding assimilation, enforcing common standards and protecting social cohesion, they repeatedly preferred denial, euphemism and administrative improvisation. The costs then appeared in housing, schools, policing, welfare, public order and increasingly fragmented communities.

The two systems reinforce each other negatively. A gigantic welfare state makes uncontrolled immigration more expensive; social fragmentation makes reform harder; weak growth makes redistribution less sustainable; higher taxes damage competitiveness.

Declining competitiveness, rising living costs, deteriorating schools and degraded public services produce demands for more subsidies and state protections that the state cannot possibly meet, increasing public anger.

These conditions are exploited by the left and by radical Islamists whose preference is for domination, not assimilation, as integration has too often failed despite France’s efforts at government-managed integration. France’s naive immigration model is built on Republican Universalism—color-blind citizenship that assumes arrivals will share civic values regardless of their origins or religion, welcoming them into a political community of equals.

France has its “Law Reinforcing Respect for the Principles of the Republic” to combat Islamist separatism,² and it has poured capital into apprenticeships, with the number of apprentices more than doubling to over one million by December 2023.³ But the Islamists do not want assimilation; they seek domination. A French government intelligence report warned of the growing presence of the Muslim Brotherhood and its threat to French national unity.⁴ It described its practice of “entryism”—infiltrating public institutions, schools, and local sports and cultural clubs to gradually shift social rules from the bottom up.

The report identified 139 places of worship affiliated with the movement across the departments (states), and another 68 considered close to it, together drawing an estimated 91,000 worshippers on Fridays.⁵ Recent French parliamentary investigations and public reports have scrutinized ties between certain far-left politicians—specifically within Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s La France Insoumise—and organizations or activists accused of Islamist entryism or pro-Palestinian mobilization targeting the Muslim electorate.⁶

Critics use the contested term “Islamo-leftism” to describe the growing tactical alliance between elements of the radical left (such as La France Insoumise) and Islamist movements or networks. The phrase was introduced into French political and academic discourse by political scientist Pierre-André Taguieff in the early 2000s to describe how some anti-globalist or far-left groups converged with radical Islamist positions around anti-Zionism and pro-Palestinian advocacy.⁷

Analysts and critics sometimes use the label “red–green–brown alliance” to describe an intersection where leftists (red), Islamists (green), and far-right actors (brown) share anti-establishment, anti-Western, or anti-status-quo sentiments.⁸

Critics, conservative politicians, and figures in the French government argue that parts of the radical left abandon secularism (laïcité) and republican values by accommodating or normalizing political Islam to win suburban and minority votes. Opponents view the convergence as a dangerous tactical miscalculation where secular progressives provide an intellectual vocabulary for reactionary or coercive religious movements. While the two would seem incompatible on the surface, in reality, one produces the fractures, the other exploits them.

Yes, the anger over cost of living and living conditions is real. The school system has deteriorated.⁹ Public services have crumbled. Integration has too often failed, under the watchful eyes of every government. But the vandals, the looters, and the arsonists aren’t the product of a random weekend mishap.¹⁰ They’re the product of a system that has tolerated, year after year, the rule of law no longer applying the same way everywhere while opening its borders to an invasion of individuals unwilling to assimilate.

It’s not the exclusive fault of one side. It’s the shared responsibility of those who have governed France since the 1970s. The right, once in power, has often talked tough and acted little, out of fear of unpopularity or electoral calculations. No one has truly wanted to shoulder the political cost of restoring order and putting an end to the abdications. For decades, they allowed a culture of leniency to take root when it comes to delinquency, trafficking, violence, and attacks on property and people.

French leaders have preferred speeches, sociological excuses, and abdications of authority over applying the law firmly and consistently. Result: a portion of the population has internalized that you can smash, steal, and burn without any real consequences. For two decades, France’s leaders have governed hand in hand with Brussels globalism. Macron, Ursula von der Leyen, the Commission—the same reflexes, the same contempt for nations while letting immigration manage itself.

They let life become increasingly unaffordable. And every time someone dared say it, they labeled them racist, fascist, far-right. This system manufactured chaos. And today, it’s the far left and its radical Islamic allies who are reaping the political benefits. Globalist centrism created the void. The far left rushed into it, opening the door to unrestricted immigration—disproportionately Muslim—whose culture rejects assimilation and eagerly aligns with the far left in delegitimizing and demoting Western institutions and their Judeo-Christian origins.

The unrest in France is spilling across borders, inspiring similar demonstrations in Belgium and parallel protests in Portugal and Italy.¹¹ In the internet and social media age, civil unrest does not stop at national borders. Riots can act as a psychological catalyst across Western democracies, where citizens face identical grievances regarding inflation, economic inequality, and distrust of political elites—fueled by the radical left and its alliance with radical Islam and the growing number of easily exploitable, unassimilated migrants and their children.

While this alliance presents itself as a partnership for liberation, the bond between the far left and radical Islam is forged not in shared ideals but in shared hatred—of Western civilization, capitalism, and perceived colonialism. For the far left, the West represents systemic oppression; for Islamists, it symbolizes moral decay and an obstacle to religious domination. Together, they occupy the Trojan Horse that advances under the banner of justice, using moral language to disguise their intent to dismantle the foundations of democracy and replace them with coercive, illiberal alternatives.

The warning from France is not that every welfare program is socialism, every immigrant rejects integration, or every protest threatens civilization. It’s that no country can indefinitely promise benefits without financing them, provide open borders and expect natural assimilation, demand social cohesion without building it, and defend the rule of law without applying it consistently.

France is the canary in the coal mine. The question is whether the rest of the West will heed the warning.

Footnotes

  1. INSEE, “General Government Accounts in 2025,” Insee Première, no. 2106, May 2026, https://www.insee.fr/en/statistiques/9008766. Revised annual figures: public spending 57.3% of GDP, deficit 5.1% of GDP (down from 5.8% in 2024), public debt 115.7% of GDP.
  2. Law no. 2021-1109 of August 24, 2021 “confortant le respect des principes de la République” (reinforcing respect for the principles of the Republic), aimed at combating separatism and radical Islam. Vie-publique.fr, https://www.vie-publique.fr/loi/277621-loi-separatisme-respect-des-principes-de-la-republique-24-aout-2021.
  3. INSEE, “Depuis 2018, l’apprentissage s’ouvre massivement aux formations de l’enseignement supérieur,” https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/8305566. The number of apprentices more than doubled in five years, from 429,900 in 2017 to 1,021,500 in December 2023, after the 2018 reform and exceptional employer aid.
  4. “Les Frères musulmans et islamisme politique en France,” the 73-page government-commissioned intelligence report presented to the Interior Minister in May 2025. Public Sénat, “Frères musulmans : ce que révèle le rapport commandé par l’exécutif,” May 20, 2025, https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/politique/freres-musulmans-ce-que-revele-le-rapport-commande-par-lexecutif; Le Monde, “Muslim Brotherhood’s influence in France: What the controversial report reveals,” May 22, 2025, https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2025/05/22/muslim-brotherhood-s-influence-in-france-what-the-controversial-report-reveals_6741529_7.html.
  5. La Croix, “Frères musulmans : un rapport met en garde contre une ‘menace pour la cohésion nationale’,” May 20, 2025, https://www.la-croix.com/religion/freres-musulmans-un-rapport-met-en-garde-contre-une-menace-pour-la-cohesion-nationale-20250520. The report cautions that a worshipper attending a mosque of the movement is “by no means necessarily a member,” and estimates only 400 to 1,000 individuals in France as formal members of the Muslim Brotherhood (Le Monde, May 22, 2025).
  6. Assemblée nationale, Report no. 2235 of the commission of inquiry on links between political movements and networks propagating Islamist ideology, deposited December 10, 2025, https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/rapports/cepolisl/l17b2235_rapport-enquete. The report documented “convergences and displayed proximities” between certain officials—principally in La France Insoumise—and individuals promoting Islamist ideology, while finding no “structured, demonstrable links” between the parties and Islamist movements as such. See also franceinfo’s summary of the contested conclusions, https://www.franceinfo.fr/politique/parlement-francais/assemblee-nationale/liens-entre-partis-politiques-et-islamisme-ce-qu-il-faut-retenir-des-conclusions-contestees-de-la-commission-d-enquete_7687759.html.
  7. Pierre-André Taguieff, interview, Le Point, November 21, 2020, https://www.lepoint.fr/debats/pierre-andre-taguieff-certains-islamo-gauchistes-sont-islamismophiles-21-11-2020-2402060_2.php. Taguieff, a director of research at the CNRS, coined “islamo-gauchisme” in the early 2000s (in La Nouvelle Judéophobie, 2002). The CNRS has stated that the term is a political slogan that “does not correspond to any scientific reality”: CNRS communiqué, February 17, 2021, https://www.cnrs.fr/fr/presse/l-islamogauchisme-nest-pas-une-realite-scientifique.
  8. The term “red–green–brown alliance” (alliance rouge–verte–brune) originated in France in the early 2000s and refers to an alleged convergence of leftists (red), Islamists (green) and the far right (brown); it was coined by the essayist Alexandre del Valle in Le Figaro in April 2002. Wikipedia, “Red–green–brown alliance,” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-green-brown_alliance.
  9. OECD, PISA 2022 Results: Country Note — France, https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/pisa-2022-results-volume-i-and-ii-country-notes_ed6fbcc5-en/france_8008535b-en.html. France’s results were down compared to 2018 in mathematics and reading, and among the lowest ever measured; the decline in mathematics was described as unprecedented in the country’s PISA record.
  10. On October 17, 2026, roughly 550,000 people marched nationwide against rising living costs and deteriorating public services (organizers put turnout near 800,000); about 2,400 people were arrested, nearly 1,000 officers were injured, and rioters torched the historic Limoges city hall. Associated Press, “How France’s worst rioting in years erupted,” October 20, 2026, https://apnews.com/article/france-protests-riots-looting-ca52b503a4ac8b2a489109f7de852847; Reuters, “France faces aftermath of worst unrest in years,” October 18, 2026, https://www.reuters.com/5f374b32b07b/world/europe/france-faces-aftermath-worst-unrest-years-2026-10-18/.
  11. Reuters, October 17, 2026, https://www.reuters.com/5f374b32b07b/world/students-trade-unions-yellow-vests-set-protest-across-france-2026-10-17/. Belgium, Portugal and Italy also faced smaller-scale protests the same day: several hundred mostly young people protested in Brussels “partly inspired by those in France,” some clashing with police; a cost-of-living march in Milan degenerated into disorder, with police clearing the cathedral square with tear gas.

-30-

Paul Vallas formerly ran the public school systems in Chicago, Philadelphia and the Louisiana Recovery School District. He was a candidate for Mayor of Chicago.

Comments 32

  1. A very thoughtful and frightening essay. I truly fear for our country. If the ANY DSA candidate wins this November get ready because what’s happening in France will happen here !

  2. Than you Paul, do not forget to turn out the light when leaving.
    Not only is France the “canary” but all of Western Europe including Britain, Ireland, Spain, and the Germanic countries are a flock of pigeon skata so to speak. Ironically, it is the the Eastern European countries where there is some hope of for fiscal and social sanity. As early as 2001 and definitely in 2011 did French author Renaud Camus warn of the ” Great Replacement” for which he was smeared with the usual mud of “white nationalism” and “far right conspiracy theory” (where have we heard that before.) He was subsequenty banned from Twitter until Musk created “X.”
    Vote next Tuesday like your life and culture depends upon it!

      1. Russia may very well protect Eastern Europe from Western Europe. I believe bilateral relations with Russia and America First is very positive. It’s the Left that hates and fears Russia the most, so we have something in common at face value perhaps.

        Trump is re ording things like a great manager does

  3. Thank you Paul for a well reasoned perspective.
    While I will miss John’s columns and voice I will also miss the assembly of great minds that have found a place to share their perspectives as well. I wish that this place that John created would continue as a forum for the folks that share their perspectives and thoughts.
    We need this community to continue.

  4. Great article, very informative. We read it and we fear what may possibly happen here. Unfortunately those of us subscribing to Kass are of the conservative nature. The people that need to be reading this article don’t subscribe here. The blue voters have no clue and do not want to know. Scary times. God save America!

  5. Something you neglected to mention:

    The pensioneer class broke the social-contract required to fund their benefits – they stopped having children. The working-age class makes up a smaller percentage of the overall population than they have at any time in French history. The pensioneer class refuses to revisit their benefits package, even though they changed the social contract.

    This means a smaller number of workers has to generate all the revenue for society at-large, while the pensioneers happily vote-down any reduction to their package. This directly results in the following – capital for societal expenses such as education, medical care for non-pensioneer scenarios (maternity wards), industry-creation/job-creation dry up as more and more capital is diverted to pensioneers. This is the real reason for the riots.

    Immigrants are playing a role as well, although it’s more of a follow-on role of “joining a riot”.

    This is the real song of the canary, and this song is coming to canaries in the US, but you have to be willing to be honest to hear it.

  6. Well said Paul. Should be noted that 2 Catholic churches recently were converted to Islamic centers in Glennwood and Hometown IL. Closures were related to lack of attendance and financial hardship. These types of acquisitions are not to be taken lightly; they are strategic just as Constantinople was conquest driven. Many new Mosques are being built without much concern for financing, but to capture the brick and mortar of our Christian faith is as or more important than the construction of a new building. This begs us to attend the services of our Christian faith before those seats are occupied by those not so interested in our well-being.
    It should also be noted that a Chicago Bear football player recently decided to leave the sideline during the National Anthem and proceed to the endzone to assume the Muslim prayer position. The NFL took no position to discipline this violation of league protocol. The news defended the action as the player is actually a Christian? Most Christians I know pray on their hands and knees. This is just another strategic signal of what’s coming, and it ain’t gonna be pretty. Dominus vobiscum.

  7. One thing missing from this column is what happens when the Red/Green alliance finally overthrows the old order. The Reds think they’ll be able to subdue or control their Muslim allies. The Iranian Revolution and the overthrow of the Shah shows that 7th century Mullahs are more ruthless than 20th century commies. Considering every Red revolution is based on the French Revolutionary model, make common cause with disparate groups, then liquidate them once you overthrow the king, you’d think the French would be smarter about this.

  8. The majority of the voters most likely to France this country live in the blue hellhole cities first in line for arson, looting and street violence. The viral video of the French woman sobbing as she attempts to commiserate with those thugs smashing and emptying her store is the perfect metaphor.

  9. Paul,
    Thank you for stating the obvious and bringing the receipts. How were you not elected Mayor? I would like to see any Democrat running for office write a column, from THEIR own hand, on any subject they believe and bring the receipts. They can’t, because in the words of DJT, they’re Dumb-o-crats. Patrick J. Buchanan predicted what is happening in France back in 2002 with his book “The Death of the West – How Dying Populations and Immigrant Invasions Imperil Our Country and Civilization”; as written on the inside Dust Jacket: “Europe will be inundated by an Islamic-Arab-African invasion,…”

    John,
    Please do not shut down JohnKassNews.com. Let someone else run it. I dare to say with much confidence, all your subscribers, me included, will continue to subscribe because we need to read the common sense opinions opposing the radical left. You have not let western civilization fall as you mentioned in your Podcast. It’s upon all of us conservatives to keep our values thriving, as you have done for decades. GOD Bless you and your family.

  10. Paul Vallas’s commentary is an important counterpoint to the political nihilism being pushed for various reasons into our local and national spotlight.

    Consider Paul assuming the lead position for the Kassnews editorial space. I think his essays are outstanding. Moreover, the broadcast media, perhaps Fox News, should be encouraged to create a segment for Paul Vallas. He deserves a platform. Consider as well Channel 11, WTTW. It would be an obvious choice to provide Paul a platform to counter the left wing bias implicit in some of its reporting. Think of that: Channel 11 regularly including moderate to conservative points of view by Paul in its political, law enforcement and social reporting. Miracles sometime happen.

  11. It’ll be the birthrate that cements the demise of Europe’s Western civilization. Those week-kneed governments act like they’re always one compromise away from solving their problems.

    Hang on to this column for a few more years and you can us your word processor’s “global search and replace” feature to change the continent and countries’ names

  12. Too many Americans, likely misled by the legacy media, look at these “protests” and think “typical French”. No, these are different, these are truly scary.

    This time, it will be up the French to save themselves. I have some hope that they will. I’d like to visit someday, I hear it’s beautiful. But I won’t be beautiful and I won’t visit if it’s a Muslim country.

  13. Amen and Amen, Paul. SO well written and full of truth – a great example of a voice crying in the wilderness trying to rouse those who need to hear it!!!!!

  14. Paul,
    Spot on assessment of the challenges before us. We can readily see the repurcussions of unlimited and uncontrolled immigration policies abroad, and now on our own shores. With the advent of socialist and communist candidate choices on upcoming ballots, we’d better wake up before Islam becomes a national powerhouse, eroding our constitution and way of life. I just can’t figure out why these people lie, cheat and steal their way to come to the USA, from countries that have enslaved or entrapped them, and then as they arrive, they start to turn this country into the s–thole they left! Defies logic. Maybe someone smarter than me can explain it to all of us….thanks again, and as we say “theos filaxee!”

  15. Mr. Vallas,
    Thank you for another insightful column. I really appreciate the intelligent writers who contribute to Mr. Kass’ column. I hope that this format will continue long after Elvis has left the building.

  16. Thanks again Paul after reading your latest I feel we’re an election away to becoming France and expanding to Eastern Europe. It has already started in Poland and who knows where Russia will continue to apply its ruthless Communistic aggression

  17. Well done. As Islam comes for Germany, England, Ireland, Scandinavia, and the rest of Western Europe, if Democrats and their Islamist candidates, add in the “I always feel guilty” types like Soros, Raskin, Prizker, add in the poison that higher ed has become, we’re doomed.

  18. God Bless Paul, for shouldering the bulk of this wonderful news site! Paul Vallas has done heroic work during John Kass’ s time off and heroically filled the breach in columns!

    God Bless this brilliant and generous man!

  19. Thank you, Mr. Vallas, for this in-depth presentation of the dire political and social situation in France and its “incipient” movement here in the US.

    We have always appreciated your deeply insightful columns and will miss them in the future. I second the wishes of the many respondents before me that JohnKassNews continue in some format. Your voice needs to continue to be heard.

  20. Thank you, Paul.
    Well said and frightening. The lack of assimilation is appalling.
    Out of control immigration leads to chaos. Wake up people and Vote!

    And I also would like this column to continue, the guest writers have been outstanding.

  21. Antisemitism is the Canary in the coal mine, and it is the idea and philosophy that ties the soul together
    And for these people, it is the gift that keeps on giving

Leave a Reply