What Tree Do We Plant Now?
By John Kass
August 20th, 2025
I’m a fool for not listening to the woodpecker. He was trying to tell me something. But I had fallen away from woodcraft and the natural world.
There was a time I was in tune with nature, but after a series of health issues, I could not walk to hunt a field or train a dog. I couldn’t climb a riverbank or step over those slippery river rocks in that river up north. And that’s when your hearing begins to go.
At dinner the other night with our wives, I was telling this story about the loss of natural language to two great fly fishermen, Steve the Pilot and Ross the Baker. I think they understood. I didn’t tell it for a pity party. I knew what the beeping monitors in a hospital were all about, but a woodpecker pounding his head against a tree was incomprehensible.
I had lost the language.
I suppose I know what woodpeckers were searching for, but I didn’t put together the pounding sound with the reason for the pounding. It was God talking and I was too stubborn to understand or listen to Him. Perhaps some of you heard my voice all agitated during opening monologues of the Chicago Way podcast I used to record while sitting under that great Tulip tree in the backyard when the woodpecker began pounding.
It wasn’t my first war with woodpeckers either. Our home back in Western Springs was targeted, and once at the paper I wondered aloud about getting a pellet gun and blowing them off the wall. That’s when a deranged leftist colleague and bird watcher threatened me with federal bird authorities that would cost me thousands of dollars and perhaps my freedom.
“You’d really do that to me Julie?”
“Yes, I would,” she promised loudly so everyone could hear.
The Tribune was going woke and I didn’t listen.
Woodpeckers are drawn to rotting wood. And leftists are drawn to decaying institutions. That’s also part of the natural world.
That magnificent tree was about 70 feet tall and the reason we bought the house. The trees reminded us of Western Springs. The reason they’re called Tulip Trees?
Every spring they produce delicate tulip-like blossoms.
Damn woodpecker.
That magnificent tree was about 70 feet tall and the reason we bought the house. We loved that tree. The trees of our new neighborhood reminded us of Western Springs. The reason these are called Tulip Trees?
Every spring they produce delicate tulip-like blossoms. And they give great shade.
We put two dark green Adirondack chairs at the trunk. Our patio was shaded, and we had put my parents’ heavy black wrought-iron table and chairs to enjoy that shade. You needed linebackers to move those chairs. From there we listened to Music of the Baroque.
We’d have drinks out there, and sampled many of Betty’s classic meals, from grilled Branzino to grilled Tuscan Chicken under bricks (rosemary, garlic, lemon) and sipped on ice-cold summer rosé . The boys proudly spit-roasted their whole Easter Paschal Lamb under that tree, and the Homeric Italian and Greek sausage from Joseph’s Finest Meats and the entire family would enjoy the summer shade.
And a dessert of Greek yogurt, honey and walnuts with strong coffee. Or perhaps just watermelon. And maybe a small cold glass of limoncello.
But then thunderstorms came.
That great, big Tulip Tree–that had withstood so many storms as it grew to lord over the house and the neighborhood–cracked under the strain of wind. We called three arborists and all gave the same diagnosis. It was terminal. There was no saving it.
So, we had it ground down to the stump.
The tomatoes and other vegetables seem happier. But we are left with a question the late great mayor Richard J. Daley of Chicago asked of those leftists that vexed him:
What trees do they plant? They didn’t plant a damn thing. All they did was whine.
A great tree is a friend, like a great dog. We’re still not over the loss of Zeus the Wonder Dog. I know Betty won’t ever get over it.
There are various possible solutions. Now I’m asking you for your advice, and some people don’t care for advice. I could advise Ukrainians strongman Zelensky to get some proper British or American tailoring so he’ll look like a grown up man, and not some nervous kid aping a Eastern European gangster. I could advise the Democrats to stop supporting lawlessness and anarchy, but they won’t listen. And Zelensky won’t listen either.
I come back to the question about trees. Fruit trees? Flowering shrub or some other shade tree. Not a spruce. A tree I can look at through the seasons I have left. A tree that might welcome the forest-green Adirondack chairs, a tree that would give us shade in what summers to come.
People, I’m willing to listen.
So what tree do we plant now?
(Copyright 2025 John Kass)
-30-
About the author: John Kass spent decades as a political writer and news columnist in Chicago working at a major metropolitan newspaper. He is co-host of The Chicago Way podcast. And he just loves his “No Chumbolone” hat, because johnkassnews.com is a “No Chumbolone” Zone where you can always get a cup of common sense.
Merchandise Now Available: If you’re looking for a gift for that hard-to-buy for special someone who has everything, just click on the link to the johnkassnews.com store.
Where else would you find a No Chumbolone™ cap or a Chicago Way™ coffee cup?
Because I know this about you: You’re not a Chumbolone.
Comments 60
I watched the crew of THE TREE MANN in Michigan City take down a majestic but decayed Mulberry tree in my backyard and marvelled at the efficient and surgical care these craftsmen went about in discarding the old corpse,
It was truly a moment of man taking on what God have wrought. God’s ways seemed very well justifies by these sober and respectful wood pathologists.
Me? I don’t plant I killed a cactus last time and have not yet gotten over that.
A beautifully shaped Buckeye will give you pleasure and provide much needed shade from
the withering rays of Old Sol. Its canopy is wide and its trunk is solid and resists those pesky Ash Borer bugs.
A Tricolor European Beech. It’s not a fast grower but it has a majestic shape and it changes color throughout the season.
The biggest tree you can find, one that a company would need a tree spade to plant. If you can find a big Sunset Maple you’ll enjoy beautiful fall colors.
Sunset maples are beautiful, we have one in our front yard … but, John seems to want something for each season and maples, while pretty all year only really “shine” in the fall.
We (my beloved and I) will take a little seedling from the yard, transplant it into a bucket for a year and then plant it. Maples grow quick. Oaks a little slower. But it’s kind of neat to help the process along.
Any Oak Tree for his area would be good.
I agree. A good Pin Oak or a Burr Oak will be good. They grow fairly fast and are a good strong hardwood. I have maples that I planted and the pin oak that I planted at least 5 years later now towers over the maples
One of my fondest moments growing up in Chicago was watching in the morning from our back den this little old man take down a huge oak tree in our neighbor’s yard. It provided subtle summer entertainment as we watched him daily climb and crawl up on the tree and dismantle this mighty oak limb by limb. He had no mechanical help or workmates in his dispatching the branches, only ropes and a saw….. old school indeed! It took him entire length of the summer, but like the determined mighty mouse he brought it down. Oh the simple pleasures of youth, sitting with my mom and grandma while sharing tea and coffee, and watching the demise of a once mighty oak.
– the cypress or the olive tree
I would go with a tree that flowers beautifully in the spring, like a cherry or ornamental pear tree. That way you can more fully enjoy the Resurrection every spring when everything comes alive with splendor.
A dogwood is beautiful in the spring.
John, plant an olive tree or perhaps a fig. Slow growing but they produce something from the Old Country.
Another tulip tree, of course. Or two so they have company.
THIS. And remember, trees are planted not just for now, but for posterity. So if you can get older trees to transplant by pros, so much the better.
I spend my summers in the Northwoods, almost to Canada. My grandfather was in the US Forest Service, a scientist and surveyor. He worked in Athens, OH, and Carbondale, IL, to reforest areas after the strip miners had been there. Sure, he was an environmentalist, but more like a “commercial environmentalist”. He valued commerce and knew the only value in a forest wasn’t its beauty.
We are surrounded by trees here. Northern White Cedars, White Pines, Balsam Firs, Black/White Spruce, Sugar Maples that make the best syrup. Paper Birches abound and there are trembling aspen the moose love to munch on. They are of this place.
You need a tree that will be of your place, but since your family enjoys the backyard table, I might have a different suggestion than a majestic White Oak, Bur Oak or beautiful maple. They are slow growing.
How about an alder? If you get the right one (George Kay and Associates in Geneva, IL could advise) it will be bushy and shady. But, alderwood is great for grilling fish. I’d get the black alder. https://www.thespruce.com/alder-trees-and-shrubs-3269701. We had one in our yard when I lived in Geneva and we loved it.
You already have. Your children, your writing and sharing, your love for others. The rest is just Stuff.
Beautifully observed, Michael. Though a fine tree is better than most stuff, the four items you note, nurtured by the friend of Zeus and that tulip tree, are superior.
We had a beautiful bald cypress and a quaking aspen from Hinsdale Nurseries that we planted a few years before we left our Willowbrook home of 35 years in December 2022. We wanted to take them with us to Tennessee but obviously couldn’t. We planted one of each at our lake home here to enjoy.
I have enjoyed watching Sycamores near my yard, they require a little room to spread but their leaves flutter in the wind. Great shade and a beautiful shape, I might suggest a trip to Morton’s Arboretum to check out what grows successfully around here.
Maple would be my suggestion. You are planting it for the next people that live there . But you can take some satisfaction from giving it a home and treating it with respect – knowing it will be a magnificent partner to your house and yard and beyond
I’m going through this now as we are losing a beautiful American Redbud. I will replace it with another Redbud when the time comes. But if you are looking for shade and a big sturdy tree I recommend two varieties of maple that I also have in my yard. They grow quickly. One is a beautiful Autumn Blaze maple that turns bright red in the fall. The other is a Norway maple that gets pretty, small light green flowers in springtime and the leaves turn a bright yellow in the fall. If I had room for another tree I would plant another Norway, it really stands out in both spring and fall. Our neighbors all admire it too!
Pin Oak. Trim it up and it will grow tall and wide. Thats what I did 6 years ago and look at it now:)
John,
Sorry to hear you lost that tree. I can relate. My wife RonnDa and I love it sit under it on a summer afternoon or evening with our nibbles and drinks and sometimes our dinner.
We have a magnificent Silver Maple that is 40 feet tall, has great shape and shades our pation from 2pm to sundown, we’d be heartbroken if we lost it. We do have an arborist trim it to take out the branches that will inevitably die AND to thin it out just enough so the rare high winds won’t have as good a chance to do great damage.
You do have to put up with the “spinners” whirlygigs” that come in spring for a little while.
Fun to see the name of a long-time friend here! Best to RonnDa and the “kids”! kb
Two different thoughts…..plant a Linden, 32 years ago we did and it’s a beautiful shade tree…second thought for 31 years we didn’t have woodpeckers and we are in a area with millions of trees then out neighbors maple died. Apparently the woodpeckers decided our house siding was perfect for pecking. They were looking for things to eat or creating a bigger hole to borrow in for the winter. We filled in their holes added spikes to keep them from returning, put balloons tied to our windows to distract them. Currently we are at a stalemate…no pecking. But not sure how long the peace will last.
Nyssa sylvatica, Black Gum. Slow-growing but offers vibrant scarlet fall foliage, wildlife value (berries for birds, nectar for bees), Great in all seasons.
John very timely column.
We got back from a short stay at the Lake in Michigan City and found one of our big old Maples that is estimated to be over 120 years old and over 80 feet tall on our parkway lost a big limb in the storms.
Fortunately no one or thing was hit. However, after the village came out and inspected it, the news was hard to take. Recent and past Lightning had split open some of its limbs and it was dying. It had to come down. No amount of reasoning would bring about another answer.
In any case, we will move on to possibly a sugar maple or white oak that will begin the cycle of life once again. May it reign over the neighborhood for another 120+ years.
Excellent column, excellent (I’m sounding like Dracula in 1931 classic: ‘Excellent, Mr. Renfield, excellent’).
But with a down tree comes rebirth of even greater beauty. We lost a massive tree due to root rot. It forced us to work on our south property that was a thicket of overgrown bushes, trees, thorn plants etc. We called in the landscaper and we now have a beautiful park like setting with huge area of flowering plants. A day doesn’t go by that if we’re outside someone doesn’t compliment us on it. That area of yours would make a great flower bed of perrienals. Go 4 it!
A sugar maple for its rich, fiery color in the fall. We had a regular canadian maple in our yard in countryside, but its fall color was gold. It was pretty, but I so envied my neighbor’s sugar 🍁 maple. Pretty all year around, but especially fall.
Great column John, I really enjoyed reading the peace that you and Betty enjoyed. I’m sorry that you lost the wonderful and shady Tulip Tree, I hope your readers can help you.
Thanks also for the mention of Mayor Richard D and Frank Sinatra, always brings a smile to my face.
And when you get around to it, I’d like to hear more about your concerns about President Zelensky.
Thanks again …
A peach tree. My Aunt’s summer place in Plymouth, Ind. had a beautiful peach tree, tall, good shade, and nothing beats peaches right from the branch when they are in season.
A white oak, John. Preferably a burr oak, but any of the slow-growing white oaks will do. I have a thing about trees and have planted dozens in my time, at every home, in three states, that I have ever owned, but the white oak is the king of trees, and the burr oak (or “bur” oak, if you prefer) is the Alpha dog even of those.
The last tree I planted—the third of three at my hand at the last residence I actually owned the dirt at (in a townhome now-no serious planting allowed) is such a tree, a burr oak I found at—of all places—a Home Depot, possibly mistakenly mixed in with various sorry ash and maple types in the barren parking lot, but quickly identified and spirited home by me to join the red and pin oaks there that I had also planted when they were mere whips. My wife now understands my illness and, looking up from her own gardening, simply waved me into the yard when I excitedly got home with it, as if to say: “ Go ahead. Dig your hole. I give up.”
I look at the deliberate planting of such a stubborn and intractable hardwood as an act of faith, and possibly acts of hope and love as well. We know, especially at our ages, that we won’t be around to see these projects to true maturity, but forge ahead anyway, on the belief that the effort will prove worth it to subsequent observers who may well sit under it in their own Adirondack chairs one day and wonder who was fool enough to plant that thing, where it is, anyway. Thus the “act of hope” part.
Anyway, that fool’s errand of a burr oak now stands, by my hurried guess when I drive by the place now owned by somebody else, at about 35 feet, and it is still an adolescent in the tree world. Certainly worth the rescue, I’d say.
So—please consider a white oak to stand in for your beloved tulip tree. The bane of woodpeckers everywhere, it will stand in defiance for generations in your memory. (not the primary reason to plant it, but a nice throw-in these days, all things considered). Give it a thought, and maybe I’ll see you at Home Depot.
Magnolia is the only way to go! Find the biggest one you can!
Red sunset maple. We love it. It is big and majestic in the summer and a brilliantly red in autumn. Give it a try.
Go with a Celebration Maple. The tree grows quickly, is stronger than a silver maple, and unlike other maples and oaks produces practically no mess from seeds, flowers, pollinators, etc.
I recommend a seedless honey locust tree. It grows fast and provides a light shade & has a nice shape and the smaller leaves are easy to clean up in the fall and, in my opinion holds up better in storms as the smaller leaves don’t act like big sails in the wind.
“ The Sunburst Honey Locust (Gleditsia triacanthos ‘Suncole’ or ‘Sunburst’) is a thornless and seedless cultivar known for its vibrant yellow new foliage that transitions to green, then back to yellow in the fall. It’s a popular choice for landscapes due to its adaptability to various conditions and attractive appearance. “ ( from an internet search ). Bob.
A redbud or magnolia would be perfect!
A Linden – it’s great for shade. And it has a beautiful shape, pyramidal to oval. We had one in our yard till it got old and had to be taken down. It gave the yard a fairy tale feel to it…
You miss Zeus. I miss Reilly. Reilly was a lost pup found on back country rod in Missouri. If not for the kind hand that picked him up he was destined for an uncertain life of a cast-off wandering the countryside. Instead, an odyssey of players and events lead him to a 15-year life in Naperville. We watched him grow and be part of us.
This is a weak analogy headed for the the tree question.
We have 30 trees on our lot. The two biggest are maples that started as helicopters blown over from a neighbor’s tree. Found them as they sprouted as “weeds” next to the house. Instead of using the string trimmer we used a shovel and transplanted them to roomy, sunny spots. Like Reilly owning our family, these trees now own the yard. Maybe look for your next tree already growing and in need of a home.
It can be seemingly inconsequential connections that make us smile.
How ‘bout a weeping willow? It looks like you have the room for one, they grow fairly quickly,and are beautiful.
Your column instantly brought to mind the poem by Joyce Kilmer that I learned in grammar school.
My favorite verse: A tree that may in summer wear, a nest of robins in her hair
Get any tree that makes you smile and that your next dog will love to pee on.
What a fun article to read while sipping my morning coffee.
Thanks, John
Tom
John,
Sorry about your tree. Our pin oak died on us and I miss it.
How about a Japanese maple? Some species are 25 ft tall and either in Spring or Fall, or both, their leaves turn various shades of reds. They are hardy trees and provide nice shade. Good luck!
Yes. Woodpeckers and linebackers. You totally missed the profound implications. Fortunately, the neurosurgeons haven’t.
We planted a tulip tree two years ago. It’s looking good already.
Maple, Linden or Catalpa trees are the fastest growing trees suitable for our Midwestern climate. Catalpa trees offer large leaves which gives shade nicely. Those Indian cigars grown on the Catalpa branches were fun when we were kids.
Nothing better, nor more american, than a Freedom Elm. Bred to resist dutch elm disease, it grows 3 feet each year and in a few years will provide a beautiful shade tree!
Sad about your tree. I see this as an easily solved circumstance, although my wife is Tree Commissioner in the tiny town just east of Michigan City and located in Michigan. Her recommendation to villagers when they lose or remove a tree is to plant native tree species as listed by the MDNR for our state. This advice to you as someone living in Indiana is the same and she asked me to forward a link to IDNR tree species? Which you will find below.
I see the best solution would be to get right back in the saddle and plant another Tulip tree for the following reasons:
1) They are very fast growing and you will be able to enjoy the shade soon enough in whatever allotment of time you have allocated to your existence. You also mentioned having enjoyed many of the characteristics of this tree species in the tree that has ceased ceased to be.
2) It is also native to Indiana, and is also on the list in the link.
3) The Tulip tree also happens to hold the honor of being the designated state tree.it checks a lot of boxes and I hope you will give this suggestion consideration.
Best regards, and Timber!
https://www.in.gov/dnr/forestry/files/fw-tree-species-list.pdf
Sound advice, Robert. Plant a native deciduous species compatible with the soil conditions in your yard.
I lost a few trees in my yard, probably 5. It’s a small lot down the hill over the tracks in beverly. I still have 6 trees around the house. My beloved maple is out growing the lot and the limbs are getting very heavy and looming over my house and the neighbors. The big trimming or removal is imminent. We love this tree. We replaced one 80- foot maple with a Catalpa…they don’t drop branches, they grow to 6o feet and give great shade. We have American elms that sprung up after the loss of countless Dutch elms in the city. Choosing the new tree is for the people that come after me, I want to give them cool shade and beautiful foliage. The great Oaks by Prospect are aging out after 200 or more years, we have a lot of decisions to make as the city replaces the historic trees. Maples are easy, but homogenous forest isn’t what we need. The mulberries are almost all gone, as is the purple poop on our windshields. Choose your trees wisely.
Try an elm tree for its quick growth in Chicago soil; Catalpas are big leaved and provide lots of shade. But anyway, plant something. That woodpecker wasn’t responsible for your tree’s decay. Nature giveth and Nature taketh away. Spinoza’s definition of Nature is God.
Redpointe Maple – urban tolerant red maple with medium to fast growth rate. I’m close to the same age as you, and face it, we need something on the faster growing side. Brilliant fall color.
Height about 45 feet and spread 30 feet, so it has a broadly pyramidal form. Planted one three summers ago and it is over 20 feet tall. A two inch B&B tree would work best for planting, if you go too big at planting it takes a while for the tree to recover and resume active growth.
This tree was a 2025 PHS Gold Medal Winner.
Seems that most of your readers are not old enough to recall the beautiful sight of entire blocks lined with elms. They formed a cathedral-like ceiling that provided elegance to the most woeful of neighborhoods. Then came the Dutch Elm disease that killed everyone of those trees one by one. Not one tree but an entire forest. The before and after pictures of every decimated block were heartbreaking. One of your readers mentioned that a new line of elms has been created to withstand that disease. I planted one years ago outside my former home in Northbrook and the last I heard it was doing well.
Hello Mr. Kass, A similar loss happened to us just after we made our escape from Illinois. We also decided recently to add a tree to our front yard and selected a gorgeous black gum. They are supposed to be hardy and so far so good. Given our advanced years you can’t exactly start out with a sapling. We found one that’s a good 10′ tall with a trunk that’s about 3 inches across at chest height. Good luck in your selection and planting. Jan H.
I think you are asking a larger question than actually what type of tree to plant. I will ponder and get back to you.
I remember the tree in our yard growing up and it was a Catalpa. It got numerous flowers in the late Spring and long hanging seed cigars in the summer. The leaves were very large. We used to pretend to smoke them.
John,
Great column! Judging by the number of replies everyone has a tree story to tell. For me it brought to life memories of my yiayia’s place near Kylini where I spend time in her care as a toddler. Big mulberry tree in the center of the courtyard/avli, eucalyptus trees to the left and two almond trees to the right. A dozen olive trees that provided a steady supply of cicadas to be caught and examined. A big fig tree that my brother and I used as an airplane until we brought one of the limps to a crash landing..no pilots were injured but I think we are still running from my aunt chasing us with a stick/kalami. Some big agave plants that produced prickly pears marking the rear boundaries along with cypress/kyparisi. I tried the fruit…picking thorns out of my mouth for hours.
Short and sweet…a tree form yellow magnolia! Medium growth rate, absolutely stunning bright yellow flowers. Reminds one of… well…a tulip tree.
Google the images
If you want shade and cooler temperatures avoiding the hot summer sun you need a grapevine supported by a wooden arbor. It is very comforting to enjoy God’s blessings under a grapevine with an abundance of grape clusters witnessing His presence.